Historic Lake George 14-mile island home on the market after 60 years
On Lake George, often called the “Queen of American Lakes,” a private island estate with more than a century of history has come to market for the first time in six decades. The 14 Mile Island estate, priced at $10.8 million, offers seven bedrooms, sweeping Adirondack views, and a rare opportunity to own a private island in one of New York’s most sought-after destinations.
The legacy of 14 Mile Island
The property’s history dates to the 18th century, when British soldiers mistakenly believed the island was 14 miles from the lake’s southern end. By 1857, the state of New York sold the property to William Smith. Over the years, it served as a hotel and steamship stop before becoming a private residence in 1905.
Designed by architect John W. Ingle, who camped on the island to study its light and landscape, the home reflects a deep connection to its natural surroundings. Clerestory windows capture daylight and moon phases, while the design integrates seamlessly with the environment.
Architecture and craftsmanship that define the estate
The residence showcases Adirondack craftsmanship with post-and-beam construction, a two-story stone fireplace, and a 3,000-square-foot southern porch supported by 17 locally quarried stone pillars. Details such as the porch’s offset to maximize sunlight highlight the thoughtful design. These architectural choices contribute to the property’s timeless character.
The Finley family, owners since 1960, have emphasized stewardship and preservation. Their work was recognized in 2019 when the estate earned the Adirondack Architectural Heritage Award. With a guesthouse, boathouse, and careful upkeep, the property stands as both a historic landmark and a livable residence.
What makes this estate rare in today’s market
The estate offers more than 2,600 feet of shoreline compared with the typical 100 to 300 feet found on most Lake George properties. It also includes a private lagoon, gazebo, and a Federal Aviation Administration-registered seaplane base, which allows direct access by private plane. Together, these features position it among the most distinctive offerings in the Adirondacks.
The Lake George real estate market has grown steadily, with a 21 percent increase in median sales prices in Warren County year-over-year as of 2023. Limited supply, especially for waterfront listings, adds to the rarity of private island properties. Globally, private island real estate was valued at more than $7 billion in 2024 and is projected to expand in the coming decade. Within this market, 14 Mile Island stands as a rare and competitive asset.
Despite its privacy, the island is accessible. Bolton Landing, with boutiques and dining, is minutes away, while Saratoga Springs, Lake Placid, Vermont, and Canada are within reach. More than a residence, the property represents cultural heritage, architectural history, and an uncommon chance to own a private island on Lake George.
Sources:
Realtor